Semilla, Brooklyn

At this intimate tasting counter, every inspired dish comes with a backstory—and every vegetable gets a chance to be front and center. #BAhot10
Image may contain Restaurant Human Person Furniture Chair Food Meal Cafeteria Food Court and Cafe
Marcus Nilsson

Meet the new model for what used to be called fine dining, the intimate, scrappy, and refreshingly unintimidating Semilla.

Some might miss the white tablecloths, bone china, and hushed tones of the country’s finest restaurants. But not me. What chef José Ramírez-Ruiz and his partner and pastry chef Pamela Yung’s 18-seat spot lacks in grandeur, it makes up for with an ambitious and inventive set menu. For $75, you receive ten works of art. I’m not exaggerating. Each visit featured several dishes that I didn’t know whether to eat or simply admire (the sliced, roasted, and reassembled carrots were an Instagram slam dunk). Meat plays a supporting role—think radish with a whipped foie gras dip—while workhorse vegetables like onion, celery, and potato are given star turns, prepared in ways that I never could have imagined. The cabbage slaw sandwich (crisp dehydrated leaves around chewy buckwheat groats) sounds like something Bilbo Baggins would take to work. But it’s a three-bite miracle. As for the always-on-the-menu sourdough bread? You’ll want to hug Yung, its creator, and ask for more. She’ll likely oblige. This is fine dining, after all.

Semilla's 10-course tasting menu, as served on June 18, 2015:

"I like the idea of always having a dish on the menu that's very classical," Ramírez-Ruiz says. Granted, this one gets its acidity from not-so-classical charred early strawberry.

Marcus Nilsson

Sunchoke peels are used to make an oil, a vinegar, and a powder, which combine in a powerful dipping sauce for a fresh take on a scallion pancake.

Marcus Nilsson

Onion party! Spring onions are steamed, while their tops are burned and puréed. Shallot trimmings are steeped in milk. Don't forget pickled ramp scapes and fried shallots.

Marcus Nilsson

At this zero-waste restaurant, last winter's citrus peels infuse the vinegar, while the oil is flavored with leftover dried lemon verbena. Get the recipe.

Marcus Nilsson

Yung invested in a small-but-powerful bread oven to show off her skills. This alt-grain bread gets swiped through bright-yellow local butter and tangy buttermilk.

Marcus Nilsson

"When I'm out of ideas, forget about a trip to Copenhagen; I go to Kalustyan's," Ramirez-Ruiz says of the NYC spice shop, where he came upon the idea for the turmeric-fermented bok choy in this kinda-Thai dish.

Marcus Nilsson

In 2010, Yung worked as the au pair for the chef at Els Casals in Catalonia, Spain. This course echoes his sausage-stuffed morel—in this case, filled with ramp bread pudding.

Marcus Nilsson

Els Casals also inspired this al dente rice, enriched with aioli and seasoned with smatterings of green garlic oil, powdered roasted leeks, red pepper juice, and foraged young daisy greens.

Marcus Nilsson

Yung's desserts are barely sweet. Here, tart sorrel sorbet and a granita made from green tomatoes macerated with vanilla, sugar, salt, and olive oil clear the palate.

Marcus Nilsson

Even the crème fraîche is house-made. As Ramirez-Ruiz points out, mega-restaurants put in the effort to make chicken stock—"and then you turn around and buy yogurt?!"

Marcus Nilsson

Yung and Ramírez-Ruiz, in front of the restaurant.

Marcus Nilsson

Get the spring greens salad recipe here.

Image may contain Plant Food Produce and Vegetable
Making your own flavored vinegar and oil might seem like a crazy thing only chefs in the Hot 10 would do, but once you make them (which is easy), your salads will enjoy instant upgrades.
View Recipe

Get in the mood for your visit to Semilla with Google Play's A Rustic Ramble station.

To read more, subscribe now. You’ll get instant access to the Best New Restaurants Issue and exclusive bonus content.