Your Mashed Potatoes Are Good. These Are Better.

Every taste of these smooth and buttery spuds aims straight for the brain’s pleasure center.
Extra buttery mashed potatoes recipe
Michael Graydon + Nikole Herriott

Every taste of these smooth and buttery spuds aims straight for the brain’s pleasure center. Follow these BA-approved tips and we guarantee your potatoes will be a Thanksgiving table hit.

Pick Your Spud

We use Yukon Golds. They deliver a richer, more buttery flavor than stalwart russets for a delicious stand-alone mash.

To Rice Is Nice

For smooth potatoes with just a hint of texture, we’re all about a ricer. Most come with different-size discs: The smaller the holes, the more refined the results.

Cream Team

Don’t skimp on the fat. Use whole milk, not low-fat or nonfat. Want to mix things up? Swap out a third of the milk for one of the following: buttermilk for tang; sour cream for a baked potato–like vibe; heavy cream for the ultimate in luxe side dishes.

Infused Can't Lose

Potatoes whipped with whole milk are delicious and a lot more palatable than those made with cream alone. Infuse that milk with herbs and aromatics, and things start to get really interesting. We love bay leaf and thyme for their autumnal notes. Also try: rosemary and sage, or a smashed garlic clove for a bit of bite.

You Can Cook 'Em Ahead

Make your mash the morning of—just be sure to reserve ½ cup of the potato cooking water before draining. Rice potatoes and return to the pot; stir in dairy, season, and cover. As serving time approaches, place the pot over low heat and add ¼ cup of the cooking water, stirring, until the mixture is hot. Add the remaining ¼ cup cooking water if needed. Serve topped with butter for visual oomph.

Get the recipe:

Image may contain Ice Cream Food Creme Dessert Cream and Butter
Drying the cooked potatoes in the pan means that they'll absorb that much more flavor from your herb-infused dairy. Don't skip this step!
View Recipe